Evaluation Tools and Rubrics for Middle School Art 1
Supporting Student Growth and Achievement
Assessment in Middle School Art 1 focuses on growth, effort, and understanding rather than artistic talent. Our approach emphasizes process over product, encouraging risk-taking and creative exploration while building foundational skills.
Daily check-ins, sketching exercises, and in-progress feedback to guide learning.
40% of GradeCompleted artworks, projects, and demonstrations of skill mastery.
40% of GradeReflection, growth documentation, and curated collection of work.
20% of GradeCriteria | Exemplary (4) | Proficient (3) | Developing (2) | Beginning (1) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Elements & Principles | Demonstrates sophisticated understanding and creative application of elements and principles | Shows good understanding and appropriate use of elements and principles | Shows basic understanding with some correct application | Limited understanding or incorrect application |
Craftsmanship | Exceptional attention to detail, neatness, and technical skill | Good craftsmanship with minor imperfections | Adequate craftsmanship with some careless areas | Poor craftsmanship or incomplete work |
Creativity & Originality | Highly original work with innovative problem-solving | Creative approach with personal interpretation | Some creativity with mostly conventional solutions | Minimal creativity or copied ideas |
Effort & Process | Exceptional effort throughout entire process | Consistent good effort with thoughtful decisions | Generally good effort with some rushing | Minimal effort or significant rushing |
Reflection & Vocabulary | Thoughtful reflection using sophisticated art vocabulary | Good reflection with appropriate vocabulary | Basic reflection with some correct vocabulary | Limited reflection or incorrect vocabulary |
Elements Portfolio Check
Week 6Design Principles Project
Week 123D Design Project
Week 18Cultural Research Project
Week 24Advanced Technique Showcase
Week 30Final Portfolio & Exhibition
Week 35